2064. Racial Disparity in the
Use of Atypical Antipsychotic Medications: Is It Still a Problem?
LA Copeland, Center for Practice Management and Outcomes Research, JE
Zeber, Serious Mental Illness Treatment Research and Evaluation Center, M
Valenstein, Center for Practice Management and Outcomes Research, FC Blow,
Serious Mental Illness Treatment Research and Evaluation Center
Objectives: Several
studies have reported racial disparities in the diagnosis and treatment of
psychiatric disorders; specifically, African-American patients with
schizophrenia were less likely to receive newer atypical antipsychotic agents
than white patients. Reasons suggested for this disparity include metabolic
differences, fewer trials of antipsychotic agents, and cultural misunderstanding
of symptoms of non-white patients. Atypicals are more expensive but patients
using them report better quality of life. The atypical clozapine is uniquely
effective for refractory schizophrenia and possibly for dually diagnosed
patients as well. This study assesses the current state of antipsychotic
prescription practices vis-à-vis race among VA patients.
Methods: We examined
pharmacy records over a 12-month period for all veterans with schizophrenia and
antipsychotic prescriptions in fiscal year 1999. Among 69,787 veterans, 26,000
(37%) had prescriptions for atypical antipsychotics, 27,491 (39%) for
conventional antipsychotics, and 16,296 (23%) for both atypical and conventional
antipsychotics. The sample was 61% white (n=42,800), 30% African-American
(n=21,032), and 9% Hispanic (n=5,955).
Results: Use of any
atypical agent during the year exhibited a significant association with
race/ethnicity. Unexpectedly, this finding was not related to being
African-American. Hispanic veterans were less likely to receive atypical agents;
whites were slightly less likely not to. Looking at specific medications, we
found that African-American (OR=0.3) and Hispanic (OR=0.3) veterans were much
less likely to receive clozapine than were white veterans. African-American
patients with schizophrenia were also less likely to receive olanzapine (OR=0.9)
while Hispanic patients were more so (OR=1.2).
Conclusions: Ethnic
disparity in the prescription of atypical vs. conventional antipsychotics is
apparent for specific agents among African-American and Hispanic veterans with
schizophrenia. The prescription of clozapine, first choice for refractory cases,
does vary greatly by race/ethnicity and may represent a lapse in race-blind
treatment practices, or may reflect concerns over serious side effects such as
white blood cell or blood glucose fluctuations.
Impact: This study offers a progress report on the VA's effort to address race-based treatment disparities among veterans with schizophrenia. Treatment of Hispanic veterans with schizophrenia merits further investigation, whereas broad disparities formerly noted between African-American and white veterans appear to now be limited to specific drugs.